The Syllabus of Errors
The document "The Syllabus of Errors" is an annex to the encyclical Quanta Cura, written on December 8, 1864. Pope Pius IX wrote it as a letter sent to all the bishops. The pope would write these principle errors instructing the Church to acknowledge and reject them. In the document, the 80 propositions essentially affirm the traditional Catholic catechism. It is a response to the rational and political liberalism ideologies of the time. The genre of this document is a letter, more specifically, the annex/attachment written to all bishops, written in the Vatican (Papal States/modern Italy). Pope Pius IX acknowledges the tension within the Church amongst Christians and instruction from secular rulers. Pope Pius IX explicitly corrects the misconceptions related to the foundational doctrine, canons and decrees of the Church.
The document consists of a greater theme of identifying and denouncing ideologies that emerge from human reason. An excerpt in Pope Pius IX's "Pantheism, Naturalism and Absolute Rationalism" emphasizes the generality of "all truths" and the "ultimate standard" found not in human reason, addressing the tension between natural human reason and religion as the source of knowledge of the truth. The pope will assert that religion is truth with a direct and authoritative tone. Therefore, Pope Pius IX expels all power in the "strength of human reason" and dismantles idolization. Amid Christianity and the Church's lure to secular philosophy and influences, the pope establishes that religion is only where ultimate truth is obtained.
Pope Pius IX explicitly asserts his authority within the Church. He lists errors from the understanding and doctrine of God (pantheism, naturalism, rationalism) (pg 187) to indifference and lack of knowledge (pg 191), the Church and its rights (pg 192), the state and civil society (pg 197), ethics (pg 202), Christian marriage (pg 204), among with many others. Within each heading and section of the document, Pope Pius IX will address specific issues within their context and assert the inaccuracy and misalignment with the Church. He is intentional in establishing authority on religion and the Church rather than human reason, even to the extent in his ending that if anyone were to "contradict this our definition, let him be anathema" (pg 257).
The Syllabus of Errors establishes the Church's authority and the Christian response to secular or contradicting viewpoints. Before this syllabus was written, the American Revolution had taken place, as the French Revolution had begun and was consecutively taking place. A few decades prior to the document's conception, the European revolution began, and the dogma of the Immaculate Conception of Mary had just been declared independently of a council. Furthermore, shortly after the document was written, the First Vatican Council established the papal's authority as that of the Bible. When Rome fell to Italian nationalism on September 20, 1870, a long process of Italian unification had finally ended. Not only was Pope Pius IX writing during the adapting power and influence of the papacy, but he also wrote with such authority that was recognized within the Church and can still be observed today within the Catholic Church.
Comments
Post a Comment